I’m not a vodka drinker. My classic opinion on it has been that it’s a fairly boring drink whose primary purpose is get drunk. I mentioned this to the gin monkey on twitter and she pointed out that this was something a lot of good people were working to change and suggested some brands I should try.
I generally try to challenge beliefs that I don’t like something until I’m really certain about it. So, armed with some expert advice, I went out and bought some vodka. Believe it or not, there was previously no vodka in my spirit collection, so these four are the first (I do have some things which claim to be vodka, but really they’re no more vodka than gin is - I’ve got the Babička for starters, as well as some infused vodkas I’ve made in the past).
The four vodkas I bought were
- Kaszebe Vestal Vodka
- Chase potato vodka
- Adnams Longshore Premium Vodka
- Sipsmith vodka
The first two were potato vodkas recommended by the monkey, the second two are Barley vodkas made by people who do two gins I really like (I thought they were actually made with the same base spirit, but now I’m not sure).
I opened these up at the office, and a few of us tried them. Here are the conclusions
Vestal Vodka
Everyone who tried this had an identical expression on their face afterwards. It can roughly be summarised as “Oh. That’s interesting”. I think I like it, but I’m not sure. It’s a bit weird - there’s definitely an earthy potato character to it. The man at the store described it as a little bit like a peaty whiskey. I can see where the description comes from, though I’m not entirely sure I agree.
I think the jury is still out on this one for me. I don’t really know if I like it or not, but I’ll happily drink more to find out.
Chase Vodka
The second potato vodka. You can definitely taste the similarity with the Vestal vodka, but it had a lot less depth of flavour. This actually worked in its favour to an extent - there’s much less of an uncertainty around whether I like this one or not. All in all, quite pleasant.
Adnams
This was my favourite of the lot (and in general it seemed a toss up between this and the chase). It was quite rich and creamy. Not terribly complex, but pleasant and interesting enough to hold up on its own. It has a slightly odd, maybe slightly musky, finish but only a hint of that and it wasn’t unpleasant.
It’s also worth noting that this one was stronger than the other 3 - 48% rather than 40%.
Sipsmith
This wasn’t very interesting. It had some of the pleasant sweetness of the others, but not much other than that to recommend it and finished with a not very pleasant chemical twang. A shame, as I rather like their gin.
Conclusion
So, am I now a vodka drinker?
Well… no, probably not.
While these were pleasant enough on their own if I’m going to be drinking neat spirits there are neat spirits I’d much rather be drinking - gin or whiskey primarily. I’ll probably give them a try occasionally to confirm my opinion here, and I will experiment with a few different ways of drinking them, but I feel reasonably comfortable that I’m not going to change this opinion wildly.
They might be nice in a cocktail, but I can’t help but feel that most of what makes them interesting versus normal vodka would be lost in that. There’s definitely an interesting flavour over just the alcohol and water and unpleasant chemical impurities taste I associate with vodka, and they’re a significantly superior spirit to what I expected, but ultimately the flavours on top of the base alcohol are not that strong, and it would be hard not to overpower them. The only thing that comes to mind as an option is a vodka martini, and I’m pretty sure I’ll just end up thinking “Well, it’s nice I suppose, but it’s not really a martini is it?”. That being said, I could be wrong and I will experiment to find out.
I’m glad I tried these, and I definitely consider them worthy additions to my collection, but I suspect I’ll have finished and replaced several bottles of my preferred spirits before I make a significant dent in the level of these.